In
Defense of Craft
A
Response to Vanishing American Craftsmanship
Bruce Gardner, owner of Homestead Timber Frames,
recently presented this lecture to the Crossville Rotary
Club in Crossville, Tennessee.
I recently had the honor
of dining with Al Hudson in Knoxville. Al is a cabinet
maker with 75 years of experience devoted to his craft.
His shop wall bears the inscription “The life so short,
the craft so long to learn.” Chaucer penned these lines
in 1380 in his The Parliament of Fowls.
Al, at age 89, designs and
builds extraordinary pieces of furniture and so I asked
him if he considered himself a Master. He slowly shook
his head and replied that he was merely a thirsty
student of his craft. I have had the good fortune to
visit with many fine craftsmen—none of whom would dare
describe themselves as “Master” and all of whom would
describe themselves as “Student”.
-
Lenny Bracket, who
trained as a temple builder in Japan
-
Dave Hickman, chair
builder in Murfreesboro
-
Peter McCurdy, timber
frame restorer in London
-
Ed Levin,
designer and timber framer in Canaan, New Hampshire
-
Natanel Aranof,
architect and restorer of Moorish temples in
Tashkent
-
Jesse Butcher,
Clinton, Tennessee who built beautiful oak baskets
None of these craftsmen
need to openly brag about their work or their skill.
Their work speaks for them and their work will live
beyond them, enriching the lives of later generations.
An obscure poet named
Henry Austin Dobson expressed it well in 1876 in his
“Ars Victrix”. Dobson wrote:
All passes. Art alone
Enduring stays to us;
The bust outlasts the throne
The coin, Tiberius
I use the word “craft” and
the word “art” interchangeably. Craft, to me, is
neither a birdhouse at a craft fair nor a macramé plant
holder. Craft is art. Craft is the product of a
lifelong pursuit. Craft (or art) possesses that certain
something that we can recognize but never adequately
explain.
I once read of the efforts
of mathematicians to define beauty in a woman’s face.
They drew angles, calculated distances form eye to chin,
chin to cheek, hairline to nose. The product of their
work fell far short of our built in ability to discern
and appreciate beauty at a glance. The perfect symmetry
of a butterfly wing, the nose of a Jersey calf, the
muscled shoulder of a stud horse, the practiced hand of
a skilful carpenter, a beautiful building.
Excellent craft earns near
immortality by being cherished, and hence maintained, by
it’s keepers. We have examples in America of good craft
such as the Fairbanks House in Dedham Mass., circa 1637,
the landscape architecture of Olmsted, the writings of
Melville and Poe, and the stone bridge we crossed to
gather here today. Our lives are enhanced by these
works.
I would like to describe for you a week in our small
shop. 
First of all we like each
other. We begin our week by sitting down together. The
first order of business is “the word of the week”. We
take turns presenting an obscure word, giving three
definitions for that word, guessing together which
definition is correct, and formulating a sentence with
the new word. The word, definition, and sentence are
posted on the shop wall and throughout the week we make
new sentences with that word. Seems trite, but the
effort is great fun.
We have added to our
repertoire words such as Luddite, felicity, crepuscular,
capstan, foudroyant, and lambent.
Here’s a sentence from a
recent week—“The Luddite, whilst working in his shop,
turned up his oil lamp creating a lambent glow across
the surface of his oak timbers.”
We go on to outline the
work ahead of us. Tuesday we applied our wax finish on
the Burke timber frame and buffed the individual oak
timbers. Wednesday we delivered the frame and began
assembly on the house site. Thursday we completed the
assembly. Friday we started with a talk on safety, a
short reading, and the crane arrived for the timber
frame raising. We put our hard hats on and went to
work. Within six hours we had completed the raising of
the timber frame that had required 100 hours of my time
to design and eight weeks for the shop to build. It is
the best timber frame we ever built, until we build the
next one.
After building my first
timber frame in 1985 I felt quite expert. By the third
or fourth frame I had begun to feel like maybe there was
much more to learn. After a couple hundred projects I
am near completely intimidated by what I do not know.
I am hungry and thirsty
for the knowledge that was possessed by the guild
trained craftsmen of the 15th century. The
guild system and capitalism are antithetical. In
America why would a young person apprentice themselves
to a master for seven years when land could be his for
the taking.
Succeeding generations of
workers received ever-less training in their trade and
so today I must begin my interview with an applicant by
handing him a tape measure and asking him to show me
16-9/16 inches. Lest I leave you with a gloomy
prospect, I hasten to add that there are signs of
improvement. It may come to pass that craftspeople will
both find opportunity to be trained and be recognized
appropriately for their growing skill.
The Timber Framers Guild
will soon have an apprentice and journeyman program in
place. It has taken us three decades to give voice to
the question, “Who will train the trainers?” We have
taught each other. We have taken apart old buildings
and studied them. And we have messed up a quantity of
otherwise perfectly good timber in our quest for
knowledge. And we have joyfully worked very hard. In
timber framing everything is either heavy or sharp. And
many things are both. Two weeks ago I could not pick up
my end of an eight hundred pound timber. My son could
but I could not. The clock ticks. Time to hasten on.
Time to teach others.
Let me tell you about
work. I treasure work. The English craftsman Eric Gill
wrote, “Leisure is secular, work is sacred.”
The John C. Campbell
School of Crafts has as the school motto, “I sing behind
the plow.” And finally from writer Annie Dillard who
was awarded the Pulitzer Prize in 1977 for Pilgrim at
Tinker Creek. Annie wrote, “How you spend your days
is, after all, how you spend your life.”
May each of you spend your
days in joyous pursuit of your life’s work.
Thank you so much for your
kindness in having me here. |